DNA evidence leads to arrest of 75-year-old man in fatal hit-and-run that killed teenager

Michael Davis,75, was arrested for Felony Hit and Run resulting in the death of 15-year-old Koa Quinton.

Witness accounts, license plate cameras and blood recovered from deployed airbags helped police identify suspect in deadly collision

During a Menifee Police press conference Tuesday, Nov. 17, it was announced that a 75-year-old Menifee man was arrested Friday, Nov. 13, in connection with a fatal hit-and-run collision that killed Koa Quinton, a 15-year-old young man. Quinton was riding an electric motocross-style motorcycle in August and was hit and killed. What followed was a three-month investigation that included witness statements, license plate recognition cameras and DNA evidence.

Michael Davis was arrested at his residence by Menifee police with assistance from the U.S. Marshals Service. He was booked on suspicion of felony hit-and-run resulting in death, with bail set at $1 million. His arraignment was scheduled for Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026.

During a news conference announcing the arrest, Menifee Chief of Police Dave Gutierrez  said DNA recovered from blood found on the deployed airbags of the suspected vehicle was matched to Davis, providing investigators with critical forensic evidence.

The arrest followed an investigation into the Aug. 12 collision on Briggs Road, just north of Garbani Road.

Menifee police officers responded to the area at approximately 8:19 p.m. after receiving a report of an unresponsive person lying in the roadway with a severe head injury.

Officers discovered the 15-year-old Menifee resident suffering from significant injuries consistent with being hit by a vehicle. American Medical Response paramedics and Cal Fire personnel responded and determined that the teenager had died.

Investigators determined the victim had been riding an off-highway electric motocross-style motorcycle, commonly referred to as an eMoto.

Witnesses provided crucial information that helped police identify the vehicle believed to have been involved in the collision.

According to police, witnesses reported seeing a white van traveling south on Briggs Road toward Garbani Road with what appeared to be a bicycle or motorcycle lodged beneath its front end.

The object eventually became dislodged, but the driver continued south without stopping or reporting the collision.

Using information provided by witnesses and automated license plate recognition cameras, investigators identified a white 2004 Toyota Sienna minivan believed to have been involved in the crash.

Police located and recovered the vehicle Aug. 15 in the 31000 block of Wickerd Road in Menifee, just three days after the teenager’s death.

The vehicle’s airbags had deployed, and investigators collected blood samples from them for forensic testing. According to Gutierrez, DNA analysis subsequently matched the blood evidence to Davis.

The forensic findings became an important part of the investigation, which continued for nearly three months before the arrest.

Gutierrez said Davis had previously been arrested for driving under the influence and had a history of drug possession charges. The chief also said Davis was initially interviewed during the investigation but declined to speak with detectives.

Investigators continued pursuing evidence and additional leads after recovering the vehicle.

During the news conference, Gutierrez credited witnesses who came forward with providing critical information that helped police identify the suspected vehicle. He said two additional investigative leads were instrumental in advancing the case, although the details of those leads were not disclosed in the information provided.

The investigation also demonstrated the role of Menifee’s automated license plate recognition camera system in helping police identify vehicles connected to criminal investigations.

Menifee encompasses approximately 48 square miles and has 29 license plate recognition cameras positioned at major intersections throughout the city.

The cameras record license plate information that law enforcement can use to identify vehicles and assist in tracing their movements.

In this case, investigators used the technology to help locate the suspected minivan shortly after the fatal collision, allowing police to recover the vehicle and preserve evidence for forensic examination.

The combination of eyewitness accounts, camera information, forensic evidence and subsequent investigative leads ultimately led to Davis’ arrest.

Although Davis was arrested on suspicion of felony hit-and-run resulting in death, police have not disclosed whether alcohol or drugs were suspected of contributing to the August collision.

Under California law, a driver involved in a collision resulting in injury or death is required to stop, provide identifying information and render reasonable assistance to anyone injured.

A felony hit-and-run charge involving a death does not, by itself, establish that the driver caused the collision or was under the influence.

Davis was scheduled to appear in court Nov. 17 during the writing of this story. The outcome of that arraignment was not available in the information provided.

The investigation remains ongoing.

Julie Reeder
Julie Reeder